Since the announcement at Comic Con 2013 that the Man of Steel sequel would ALSO be a Batman vs. Superman movie, all of the news coming out of Warner Bros. regarding the film has caused huge chatter on the interwebs. Things got even more crazy when Variety reported exclusively that Joaquin Phoenix is allegedly in talks to play Lex Luthor which, if it happens, seals the deal that Batman vs Superman could rival the never produced Superman Lives for potentially the craziest Superman movie ever and this one is definitely happening.

From Batfleck to Jason Momoa to Wonder Woman, let’s countdown our POP5 reasons why Batman vs. Superman is SO crazy, it just might work!